Julio Cesar - 6

Walter Samuel - 6.5
Lucio - 5
Yuto Nagatomo - 5
Maicon - 5.5

Andrea Poli - 5.5
Wesley Sneijder - 5
Dejan Stankovic - 5.5
Javier Zanetti - 6.5

Diego Milito - 6
Diego Forlan - 4

Subs:

Obi - 6
Giampaolo Pazzini - 6
Esteban Cambiasso - N/A

Claudio Ranieri - 6 (I'm not going to be as harsh, considering the fuckup by Lucio near the end. The chances clearly were there and the players on the pitch failed to execute them. Especially that Sneijder miss.)