View Poll Results: Who wins?

Voters
15. You may not vote on this poll
  • Shaun

    9 60.00%
  • Wings

    6 40.00%
Results 1 to 15 of 15

Thread: FIF Fantasy Draft Semi-final: Shaun - Wings

  1. #1
    ADRossi's Avatar
    Join Date
    17 Jul 10
    Posts
    7,111
    Thanked
    9,284 times
    Fav. Player
    #FreeInsigne

    Netherlands

    94

    FIF Fantasy Draft Semi-final: Shaun - Wings

    Trying to do this from my phone so bare with me as I copy formations over.

    If a moderator could create a poll that would be splendid.

    Shaun and Wings, feel free to post any comments below and I'll post them up here.

    Shaun

    <br />
0 0 0 Lukaku 0 0 0<br />
D.Silva 0 0 0 0 0 Messi<br />
0 0 0 Pjanic 0 0 0<br />
0 Modric 0 0 0 Matuidi 0<br />
F.Luis 0 0 0 0 0 Danilo<br />
0 0 T.Silva 0 Manolas 0 0<br />
0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />
deGea<br />
    I think my team is slightly better. I think the midfields are very similar. Where I have the edge is upfront as my front three is superior to his. I think Silva is a superior player to Willian, Messi trumps Ronaldo due to his playing style which services the team more. Whereas the team will have to service Ronaldo in his lineup. I also think Lukaku has more to his game than Benzema especially from a physical standpoint. In defence I think they're pretty interchangeable. Boateng and Silva are two of the world's best, but Manolas is actually having a good season while Benatia isn't (be it for injuries or whatever). Luis has been a absolute beast for Atletico recently and is having just as good a season as Alba who despite being a bigger 'name' isn't a superior player. Danilo has had a downturn recently, but that is going to happen with young players. He's still easily one of the most talented fullbacks in the world, while Azpilicueta is a more solid player I think in a one-off game Danilo could easily outshine him with his superior talents. At goalkeeper I feel De Gea and Handanovic are both top notch, but De Gea is probably better at commanding his defence and passing which gives him the edge.

    Wings

    <br />
0 0 0 Benzema 0 0 0<br />
Ronaldo 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />
0 0 0 Ozil 0 0 Willian<br />
0 0 Busquets 0 Verratti 0 0<br />
0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />
Alba 0 Benatia 0 Boateng 0 Azpilicueta<br />
0 0 0 0 0 0 0<br />
Handanovic<br />




    Shaun claims his edge is in his attack, but my three are more balanced. Messi and Silva spend lots of times running toward the center of the pitch and will leave his team exposed on the flanks – definitely not a good thing against Ronaldo and Alba. Willian may not be as flashy as Silva or Messi, but he provides the defensive steel that's missing in Shaun's attack.

    Supplying Ronaldo won't be a problem at all. I have Ozil, king of assists, and Benzema, who has had a great relationship with Ronaldo for years now. That's what tips the balance for me: proven chemistry between Ozil, Ronaldo, and Benzema. And beyond that Ronaldo can create goals all by himself. Since when does Ronaldo need service to be good? (see: Portugal NT).

    Benzema is a superior player to Lukaku. He may not be as physical as Lukaku, but he's physical enough. And what he lacks in that he makes up for with his link-up play, which Lukaku is not good enough at.

    Shaun's midfield features three good players, but they are all in unfamiliar positions. Matuidi and Modric are used to having a CDM behind them (Motta/Busquets) to cover for them, while Pjanic is a natural CM, not #10. Playing him in the hole will not get the best out of him. Modric and Matuidi will run forward, but without a CDM to cover for them, Shaun's midfield will have trouble dealing with Ozil.

    Defense I think we are pretty even except that Danilo isn't even a starter for his club. He's been benched by Carvajal. He might have potential, but this is a contest of quality, not potential. Azpilicueta and Alba are proven performers, and Benatia has been good in his injury-limited appearances.

    tl;dr: I have
    1) Proven chemistry with Ronaldo Benzema Ozil
    2) More defensive solidity on the flanks with Willian
    3) Shaun's midfielders are all out of position as they don't play as holding midfielders normally
    4) Danilo isn't even first-choice at his club
    Last edited by Shaun; 28 Apr 16 at 04:19.


  2. #2
    I'm better than Icardi Pimpin's Avatar
    Join Date
    13 Jul 11
    Posts
    14,130
    Thanked
    13,680 times
    Fav. Player
    22IcardiBroHand
    Old name
    DomesticatedPimp

    Albania

    59
    my vote goes to wings, easily has the most complete and balanced team.
    Quote Originally Posted by bandiera View Post
    referees 'without question' favour juve? i think youre overstating the effect of buying out the refs.
    Quote Originally Posted by bandiera View Post
    I did some thinking over the bench issue. I think when a player is benched, it can make them think more.

  3. #3
    Shaun's Avatar
    Join Date
    04 Mar 04
    Posts
    13,957
    Thanked
    17,839 times
    Fav. Player
    Kovacic

    Macau

    57 Forum Supporter 10 years of FIF Best Overall Poster
    I think my team is slightly better. I think the midfields are very similar. Where I have the edge is upfront as my front three is superior to his. I think Silva is a superior player to Willian, Messi trumps Ronaldo due to his playing style which services the team more. Whereas the team will have to service Ronaldo in his lineup. I also think Lukaku has more to his game than Benzema especially from a physical standpoint. In defence I think they're pretty interchangeable. Boateng and Silva are two of the world's best, but Manolas is actually having a good season while Benatia isn't (be it for injuries or whatever). Luis has been a absolute beast for Atletico recently and is having just as good a season as Alba who despite being a bigger 'name' isn't a superior player. Danilo has had a downturn recently, but that is going to happen with young players. He's still easily one of the most talented fullbacks in the world, while Azpilicueta is a more solid player I think in a one-off game Danilo could easily outshine him with his superior talents. At goalkeeper I feel De Gea and Handanovic are both top notch, but De Gea is probably better at commanding his defence and passing which gives him the edge.
    Quote Originally Posted by DM_ View Post
    Then we'll just buy the federation and create our own rules.
    Quote Originally Posted by Pimpin View Post
    I dont think juventus are willing to sell

  4. #4
    Wings's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 Aug 13
    Posts
    3,181
    Thanked
    5,077 times

    Marshall Islands

    14
    Now that I'm done with exams for now time to take a shot at Shaun:

    Shaun claims his edge is in his attack, but my three are more balanced. Messi and Silva spend lots of times running toward the center of the pitch and will leave his team exposed on the flanks – definitely not a good thing against Ronaldo and Alba. Willian may not be as flashy as Silva or Messi, but he provides the defensive steel that's missing in Shaun's attack.

    Supplying Ronaldo won't be a problem at all. I have Ozil, king of assists, and Benzema, who has had a great relationship with Ronaldo for years now. That's what tips the balance for me: proven chemistry between Ozil, Ronaldo, and Benzema. And beyond that Ronaldo can create goals all by himself. Since when does Ronaldo need service to be good? (see: Portugal NT).

    Benzema is a superior player to Lukaku. He may not be as physical as Lukaku, but he's physical enough. And what he lacks in that he makes up for with his link-up play, which Lukaku is not good enough at.

    Shaun's midfield features three good players, but they are all in unfamiliar positions. Matuidi and Modric are used to having a CDM behind them (Motta/Busquets) to cover for them, while Pjanic is a natural CM, not #10. Playing him in the hole will not get the best out of him. Modric and Matuidi will run forward, but without a CDM to cover for them, Shaun's midfield will have trouble dealing with Ozil.

    Defense I think we are pretty even except that Danilo isn't even a starter for his club. He's been benched by Carvajal. He might have potential, but this is a contest of quality, not potential. Azpilicueta and Alba are proven performers, and Benatia has been good in his injury-limited appearances.

    tl;dr: I have
    1) Proven chemistry with Ronaldo Benzema Ozil
    2) More defensive solidity on the flanks with Willian
    3) Shaun's midfielders are all out of position as they don't play as holding midfielders normally
    4) Danilo isn't even first-choice at his club

  5. Thanks (1): Dylan

  6. #5
    Wallace
    Join Date
    18 Jun 05
    Posts
    11,214
    Thanked
    10,241 times
    Fav. Player
    Wallace
    Old name
    Wallace

    Brazil

    88 Forum Supporter 10 years of FIF
    Quote Originally Posted by Wings View Post
    Matuidi and Modric are used to having a CDM behind them (Motta/Busquets) to cover for them
    Modric does not have Busquets covering for him if that's what you are trying to say.
    Wallace

  7. #6
    Handoyo's Avatar
    Join Date
    04 Mar 04
    Posts
    24,684
    Thanked
    5,721 times

    Indonesia

    32 Forum Supporter 10 years of FIF Most Important Member
    Picking Wings because I don't wanna be accused of nepotism if I pick someone I just promoted as admin

    Jokes aside, I agree with Pimp, Wings' team seems more balanced.

  8. #7
    Kakaroto's Avatar
    Join Date
    26 Dec 10
    Posts
    10,398
    Thanked
    13,187 times
    Fav. Player
    Taribo & Kallon
    Old name
    Black Jesus

    United States

    48
    Voted Shaun because I still think Wing's defensive pairing is weak and will be exploited.
    Platano Power
    You Fuck With Me You Fucking With The Best

  9. Thanks (1): MVD

  10. #8
    Javier'sSon's Avatar
    Join Date
    11 Oct 15
    Posts
    3,842
    Thanked
    4,172 times
    Fav. Player
    thank mr icardi

    Holy See

    4
    I'm actually surprised that Shaun has been leading since the start! I've echoed Wings post here before in his first match up and I think he has the strongest, most complete team in the competition. My only gripe is the double pivot but that's not nearly enough for Shaun's team to capitalise on.

    Also, I see Messi reking Boateng and earning an - infamous - penalty with Handa saving it

  11. #9
    MakeInterGreatAgain! JJM's Avatar
    Join Date
    10 Aug 07
    Posts
    31,877
    Thanked
    38,060 times
    Fav. Player
    Spalletti!
    Old name
    icardiscores

    Yugoslavia

    91 Forum Supporter Most Pessimistic Member
    Wing's team won't see the ball because Shaun has so many technically gifted players that can make you lose your shit.
    Also Wings has a very shaky CB pair. Messi vs Boateng...merry go round moment lol
    Ozil can be an inconsistent lazy af...Ronaldo thinks he is a one man team...Benzema will feal like a lone island
    Busqueta and Verratti are a good pair tbh but won't be enough to challenge the numerical superiority of Shaun's mf

  12. Thanks (1): MVD

  13. #10
    KevinB's Avatar
    Join Date
    25 Nov 10
    Posts
    9,224
    Thanked
    11,149 times
    Fav. Player
    Adriano

    Belgium

    54
    Manolas against Ronaldo, Benzema and Özil won't be shaky? And Danilo's been flopping more recently.

    Also Lukaku isn't that usefull in a team that prefers possession, see his games with Belgium. Unless Shaun brings on a counter tactic, Lukaku won't do much.
    Forza Internazionale Milano
    Buffalo KAA Gent - Belgian Champions 2014-2015


    http://forzainterforums.com/showthre...=1#post1395711

  14. Thanks (2): Armes, MVD

  15. #11
    Wings's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 Aug 13
    Posts
    3,181
    Thanked
    5,077 times

    Marshall Islands

    14
    Quote Originally Posted by ForzaMancini View Post
    Modric does not have Busquets covering for him if that's what you are trying to say.
    ?

  16. Thanks (1): MVD

  17. #12
    Kakaroto's Avatar
    Join Date
    26 Dec 10
    Posts
    10,398
    Thanked
    13,187 times
    Fav. Player
    Taribo & Kallon
    Old name
    Black Jesus

    United States

    48
    Busquets plays for Barcelona not Real Madrid so he is not covering Modric. At real Modric plays as the most defensive cm unless Casemiro plays.
    Platano Power
    You Fuck With Me You Fucking With The Best

  18. Thanks (2): MVD, Wallace

  19. #13
    Wallace
    Join Date
    18 Jun 05
    Posts
    11,214
    Thanked
    10,241 times
    Fav. Player
    Wallace
    Old name
    Wallace

    Brazil

    88 Forum Supporter 10 years of FIF
    Quote Originally Posted by Black Jesus View Post
    Busquets plays for Barcelona not Real Madrid so he is not covering Modric. At real Modric plays as the most defensive cm unless Casemiro plays.
    Yep, exactly. I think Wings just somehow got mixed up Modric is playing at Barca (?).
    Wallace

  20. Thanks (1): MVD

  21. #14
    Wings's Avatar
    Join Date
    24 Aug 13
    Posts
    3,181
    Thanked
    5,077 times

    Marshall Islands

    14
    Yeah mixed him up with Rakitic and Busquets w/Casemiro.

  22. #15
    Dylan's Avatar
    Join Date
    20 Jul 08
    Posts
    22,926
    Thanked
    20,714 times
    Fav. Player
    Walter Samuel

    Ireland

    13
    Shaun advances to the final.

  23. Thanks (2): ADRossi, Shaun

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •