Some general rules. I've done counting the first match and realized something so I'll lay it down here.
1) Please just copy & paste whatever the thread starter make. Ie, don't change the order of the players. If the thread starter list it as JC, Maicon, Lucio, Samuel, Chivu; don't go and change it to JC, Chivu, Samuel, Lucio, Maicon. It'll make life much easier.
2) You can also rate the coach, please do that.
3) With regards to subs, I'll take the liberty of considering your rating or not. I don't want to set a time limit because even by playing 5 minutes, a sub can be decisive in a match.
4) No discussions whatsoever with regards to ratings in that thread. Do it in the match thread. The ratings thread are strictly only for ratings.
Btw, it'll be something very simple, I'll just average out whatever everyone posted. In the Excel file, you won't know who vote what though. I'll just do it in the same order as the post order in the rating thread.
Any other suggestions?