- Joined
- Aug 5, 2012
- Messages
- 9,187
- Likes
- 647
- Favorite Player
- Baggio
10 years of FIF
Thanks again Uni for the constructive feedback.Quick rundown of my immediate feedback:
- goes without saying but your time and thought on these are much appreciated and everything looks immensely professional
- I stand by what I posted a few posts up, that the blue descending to black home jersey is, in my 'professional' opinion (whatever the fuck that's worth), the most 'correct' of the home iterations. This is because the colors meet and blend just once and that blend remains unbroken when viewing the entire kit from top down. At the same time, I understand you like the black of the sky to be on the top which makes perfect sense from a conceptual standpoint. Perhaps a complete reverse might look alright? Black on top, fade to blue and remain blue for the shorts and socks? Might not work. Seems really blue-heavy in my imagination already..
- if you are to use the home variation you most recently posted yesterday (black to blue, solid black shorts, solid blue socks), I would suggest:
- colouring the collar whatever the top-most colour is (in this case black)
- changing the font (I quite like the font we've been using IRL for a few seasons now. I'm not against changing font, but I don't think that particular font is complimentary)
- I can't help but feel a fluid gradient might look alright as I described in point 2. For example, if 1 = black and 5 = blue, in descending colour the whole kit would go 1-2-3-4-5-4-3-2-1, with 5 being the middle of the kit and turning point of the gradient. if you know what I mean. So for the jersey in question, I'd love to see the shorts and socks grouped as one bottom-half piece and have the gradient (which turns from black to blue near the stomach of the shirt) continue naturally onto the shorts, which start to turn black near the hems, which in turn, continue to blend into a deeper black on the socks, turning completely black near the Nike position on the socks.
This might end up looking like complete shit and I hate to ask you to do more work (it's completely normal for us to spend time just to see whether something works or not, then immediately deciding it doesn't eh) but I think it might look alright. Might look like shit too.
Will post a little more about the new away and third kits a bit later.
1. Well, I thank you guys for the time you spend giving me valuable ideas and feedback.
2. I get your point for the continuous gradient, it's clearer this way. I'm personally torn between iterations, I like them all for various reasons and they're lacking in other aspects, so I'm thinking I might create a thread where everyone interested can vote on which version is his favourite. After all, our personal tastes aren't that representative and as a guy who's worked creating apps and complex websites, testing is the best way to go, even when you're dead set on something people might prove you wrong very fast.
About the black-to-blue (top-to-bottom) suggestion, I'm afraid it wouldn't work - I guess the stars print should also continue with the blue colour and that would look dreadful on the shorts. Although in all fairness they might be received well for going to the beach.
3. Here's how it would look with a black collar. The blue one brings some balance, can't explain it, but it works better, at least for me. Although again, a fair point and I get where you're coming from.
- About the font, I'll try a version using it on the back as I managed to find it in a usable form. Personally I don't like it too much, too busy for my liking, but to be fair it might work better than the geometric fonts I tend to use that might look too generic.
- About the reflected gradient, it might work just fine, but then again the star print won't look good placed anywhere else than on the jersey I feel.
It would be a great assistance if you could share your thoughts about what would you like to see as away/3rd kit versions as well. Thanks again, greatly appreciated.
-