Mauro Icardi

Should we Sell Icardi in the summer of 2019/20


  • Total voters
    258

El Matador

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Jan 30, 2013
Messages
1,446
Likes
472
10 years of FIF
After calming down a bit and thinking I take back what I said about must selling Icardi. Although it's infuriating how he missed sitters in crucial games, he's also won us many points in the past. That being said, he is no longer indispensable as I once felt. If there is an offer that comes in the summer that will solve our FFP issues and allow us to buy Rafinha and Cancelo, I'd take it. Here's why:

1- He's a world class striker no doubt about it. However we are very reliant on him to score us goals and win us games. If he has bad games like today, or is marked out we almost have no other way of scoring, therefore no other way of winning. The type of striker icardi is has two main issues. He heavily needs service from the players around him because he can't create his own opportunities and he cannot create for his teammates(not like it fucking matters cause they can't score anyway). Because of this, it's very easy to mark him out if his teammates don't give him the right service.

2- Because of the reasons in number 1, we obviously need better attacking options. It starts with Rafinha and we also need to buy wingers. What we need more than anything is depth, because we have no player that can come off the bench and make something happen. If selling Icardi will allow us to fund those moves than I'm all for it. Sure, we might end up with a striker that scores only 18 goals instead of 28, but we'll end up with wingers and bench options who can also contribute to scoring which will give us a higher return.

3- Unfortunately, Icardi showed today that he isn't a leader. He should've gave the performance and character similar to that of Rafinha's. Even in the last game against Udinese he was flapping his hands around whenever his teammates took a shot or passed it to someone that isn't him, even when he's in a shitty position to receive the ball.

4- If we want to move forward signing players like Rafinha and Cancelo are a must. Having a world class player like Icardi is good but having more than one is even better.

5- Lets put faith in the potential of Lautaro Martinez, we gave Icardi the same faith.


Despite all those reasons, obviously the best case scenario is keeping Icardi because he's a brilliant player and instead making the money in another way and bring Icardi more support. But if that isn't possible then selling him might be the best option. All that being said, don't get me wrong he fucking choked today, fuck him.
 

K.I.

Allenatore
Allenatore
Joined
Jul 20, 2004
Messages
9,549
Likes
494
Old username
Khaled
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
Even if Cancelo is the worst player ever, all the players i mentioned deserve to be sold before him.

That also applies to Icardi BTW
 

Fapuccino

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Apr 3, 2012
Messages
15,126
Likes
913
Favorite Player
Schelotto
There is 0 reason to keep him around anymore. We can reach EL without him. With his sale we can buy some experienced players like Vidal and Mandzukic, that won't shit their pants at the thought of reaching a CL spot.

I've been one of his strongest supporters before this season, but his displays when the going gets tough has been nothing short of embarrassing. I didn't mind all the "he's a limited player" stuff, because he showed up occasionally off the ball, and was scoring. But when you can't score when you need to? Nah. Seriously fuck off.
 

Harpsabu

Allenatore
Allenatore
Joined
Jun 19, 2011
Messages
8,307
Likes
5,816
Favorite Player
Diego Milito
10 years of FIF
There is 0 reason to keep him around anymore. We can reach EL without him. With his sale we can buy some experienced players like Vidal and Mandzukic, that won't shit their pants at the thought of reaching a CL spot.

I've been one of his strongest supporters before this season, but his displays when the going gets tough has been nothing short of embarrassing. I didn't mind all the "he's a limited player" stuff, because he showed up occasionally off the ball, and was scoring. But when you can't score when you need to? Nah. Seriously fuck off.

If we sell a 25 yo close to wc striker to sign vidal and fucking Mandzukic i give up on this club
 

Fapuccino

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Apr 3, 2012
Messages
15,126
Likes
913
Favorite Player
Schelotto
If we sell a 25 yo close to wc striker to sign vidal and fucking Mandzukic i give up on this club

Please don't make me spit out my food. WC strikers don't shit their pants against Sassuolo and Torino because they're too scared of reaching 4th place in Serie A.

Vidal and Mandzukic will guarantee us one thing that Icardi can't, which is 4th place.
 

CoolMan44

Allenatore
Allenatore
Joined
Feb 18, 2012
Messages
5,697
Likes
2,076
No you didn't say that but you said he worked better for Barcelona and that's complete bullshit. He would have produced more being in the center and that you even compare him to Eto'o is ridicolous and suicidal worthy.

Barcelona bought a CF to play at the LW. And isn't the only transfer they've done that ridicolous switch of positions. It is proven now that it doesn't fucking matter if Messi is in the ST or the RW because he can still produce in other ways and be as significance(spelling). At that time Messi was a fucking baby who got outshined by Zlatan and was moved then to ST position. Now when Suarez came he was back at RW.

How is it bullshit that Villa worked out for Barca than Zlatan? Suicidal worthy :palm:? It sounds like you have some serious issues if you think of that because of a player's positioning.

You said that you can't think of anyone being happy to play out of position. I said that's probably true but I'm sure they are ok if they do it in order for the team to win. How you came to that being a comparison between Villa and Eto'o, I have no idea. I'm pretty sure that you don't know either given that you somehow went from talking about Villa being a schoolboy, to the fact that no one is happy being played out of position, to then getting butthurt after assuming there was a comparison between Villa and Eto'o as players, to the being butthurt about Zlatan vs. Messi.

Not surprising given most of your previous posts though;)
 

varmin

Allenatore
Allenatore
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
9,438
Likes
8,970
Forum Supporter
Most Improved Member
I think we shall sell him and get these 110 mln. He is great goalscorer and predator in penalty area but nothing more. People here (including me) blame Candreva, Perisic and our midfield for not creating enough chances and that is not all truth. Against Torino, Milan and Sassuolo we created chances enough but all were wasted and Icardi is the protagonist here. I'm agree that Perisic and Candreva are limited and very one-dimensional players but Icardi is the same. He is part of the problem, not the victim here. His contribution to our attacks outside of penalty area is close to zero. Peope are crying that we don't attack trough the center. How to do this when Icardi is incapable to win a first ball and distributed it. This forced all our attacks to go to the wings.
I'd sell Icardi and take someone else. Timo Werner is great young forward but will cost at least 60 mln. Milik from Napoli also could work fine for us and probably will be around 25-30 mln. Benzema is another option if leaves Real even thou his age is worrying.
 
Last edited:

Luka

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Jul 24, 2006
Messages
16,648
Likes
36
Favorite Player
Black & Blue
10 years of FIF
Can anybody who is following closely european football can tell me whether there is any captain in top european club with as much drama around him as Icardi? By drama I mean Wanda shit, his biography and feud with ultras, and especially the contract shit?
 

Maslany

Allenatore
Allenatore
Joined
Sep 2, 2009
Messages
5,066
Likes
641
Favorite Player
Javier Zanetti
Old username
Natasha
10 years of FIF
As much as it hurts me, he should be sold. And i am sure we will find a way to find a new good striker.. maybe even rely on Martinez. We never gave a true chance to Barbosa for fuck sakes, especially at Icardi's position.

He is too much of a burden now, missing all those easy chances that the team feeds him. That is unacceptable.. our game plan is mostly suited to nurture him. I'm sorry Icardi, this should be a farewell.
 

A.l.i

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Dec 4, 2006
Messages
10,112
Likes
5
Favorite Player
Il Capitano
10 years of FIF
He needs to leave for the good of his career. To achieve his ambitions, trophies and international recognition.
 

cherntodd

Primavera
Primavera
Joined
Sep 12, 2016
Messages
15
Likes
0
Favorite Player
Diego Milito
what's this obsession with Cancelo, do you fucks just watch highlights and not the whole games?

HE IS SHOCKINGLY BAD

I dont think he is that bad because he can attack the right flank by himself. The thing is his defense has big problems and a noticable amount of passes made by him are too casual and even irresponsible.
 

nurko

Allenatore
Allenatore
Joined
Apr 11, 2011
Messages
6,466
Likes
913
Favorite Player
Il Capitano
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
Can anybody who is following closely european football can tell me whether there is any captain in top european club with as much drama around him as Icardi? By drama I mean Wanda shit, his biography and feud with ultras, and especially the contract shit?

Well there was Terry and the affair. Giggs had an affair with his brother's wife but I can't remember if that happened during playing days or not.
 

JJM

morepoststhanu
La Grande Inter
Joined
Aug 10, 2007
Messages
40,895
Likes
59
Favorite Player
ur mom
Old username
icardiscores
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
He was the worst player on the pitch yesterday...thanks Capitano!
In truth I don't think anyone really wants him...and he will stay here when wandita gets her contract bump from turd man Ausilio... always the same story and outcome
He is a good striker and isngonna stay here for long time but he will never be a JZ like player (not even Milito status)because of Wanda

- - - Updated - - -

He was the worst player on the pitch yesterday...thanks Capitano!
In truth I don't think anyone really wants him...and he will stay here when wandita gets her contract bump from turd man Ausilio... always the same story and outcome
He is a good striker and is gonna stay here for long time but he will never be a JZ like player (not even Milito status)because of Wanda
 

Il Drago

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Dec 21, 2015
Messages
20,809
Likes
32,668
Favorite Player
Wesley Sneijder
Best Football Poster
Best Overall Poster
He was the worst player on the pitch yesterday...thanks Capitano!
In truth I don't think anyone really wants him...and he will stay here when wandita gets her contract bump from turd man Ausilio... always the same story and outcome
He is a good striker and isngonna stay here for long time but he will never be a JZ like player (not even Milito status)because of Wanda

- - - Updated - - -

He was the worst player on the pitch yesterday...thanks Capitano!
In truth I don't think anyone really wants him...and he will stay here when wandita gets her contract bump from turd man Ausilio... always the same story and outcome
He is a good striker and is gonna stay here for long time but he will never be a JZ like player (not even Milito status)because of Wanda

This is the ugly truth many people don't want to hear. We are discussing Icardi's future as if there are clubs left and right willing to pay his release clause and it's only up to Inter and Icardi to decide what they want to do. The best offer we have received for Icardi is the one from Napoli two years ago. 45m + Gabbiadini for Icardi + Santon. Apart from that, there are only rumours but no official offer for him.
 

YoramG

Allenatore
Allenatore
Joined
May 19, 2013
Messages
7,554
Likes
7,654
Favorite Player
Zanetti
10 years of FIF
Thinking about it, it would would be painful to see him play in someone else's colours. But he should still probably go. Won't Chelsea be in the market for a striker? PSG/Real maybe, to replace Cavani/Benzema?
 

firmino

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Nov 23, 2015
Messages
12,960
Likes
14
i would sell him. yeah, he scored nearly 30 goals, but he also misses too many easy chances when he's on a bad day and is as 'streaky' as it gets.

i know it would be risky but we sold ibrahimovic and created a better Inter, so it doesn't necessarily have to be a disaster.
 

Wallace

Marotta FC
La Grande Inter
Joined
Jun 18, 2005
Messages
14,190
Likes
19
Favorite Player
Marotta
Old username
Wallace
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
We created a better Inter by selling Zlatan because we were offered Eto'o. It's hard to say if we would have been so well off if we were given cash and we had to find a replacement ourselves.

We have been assuming we would get 100mil cash for Icardi.

But what if we were offered Benzema + 20mil, would anyone here consider this deal seriously?
 

Ziyad

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Mar 4, 2004
Messages
12,665
Likes
8
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
He shouldn't be a priority to sell. Keep him as much as you can. He is a good player from a marketing perspective too. If you have to sell you sell candreva, Vecino Perisic and even Handa if you have to from that starting lineup first. Then you sell the garbage like Borja and Santon and Eder ( if anyone would have them) and Ranochia . Not to mention that we have Kdog,yoshi and barbosa that can add to the amount we need to balance things.

after that you keep Rafi and Cancello and get some players from Serie A and promote some of the primavera if we have to. Other than that you are just putting yourself back into that vicious suckle over and over again.
 

varmin

Allenatore
Allenatore
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
9,438
Likes
8,970
Forum Supporter
Most Improved Member
But what if we were offered Benzema + 20mil, would anyone here consider this deal seriously?

if we were offered Benzema + 60mil, i'd take it in a heartbeat.
 

.h.

Part time Lazarus
La Grande Inter
Joined
Jun 8, 2005
Messages
29,298
Likes
7,372
Favorite Player
Inter1-0Wanda
Old username
browha
Forum Supporter
10 years of FIF
We can't afford him.salary is huge.
 
Top