First of all, thanks for the update and thank you for adding the 'FIF Black' style, it does make the forum looks good.
Ratings are also a very nice addition, however, I think good features like these ratings are often overlooked, perhaps due to less visible access to users. How about just adding this feature directly to the sidebar? This will be more obvious for users, at least for desktop users.
Also, although this might be too much to ask for, it would be great if it added a comment feature for each player and maybe an option for voting for the best comments, the results would probably look like the sort of summary that Sempreinter is used to.