100% agreed. He simply doesn't offer enough.
Some might say I'm being greedy or unrealistic. After all, it was Gagliardini who reacted quickest to Biraghi's corner being cleared, slid in and got the ball to Brozovic who set up Lautaro for our opener vs Sassuolo. It was a great bit of ball recovery. He then played a great first-touch pass to get Lautaro 1v1 with the keeper too. He actually had a very solid first half. But its
still not enough for me. Why? Where was he when we were getting torn to shreds in the last 20 minutes? How much defensive strength or attacking threat did he insert when he came on at Camp Nou?
I can't blame a guy who his natural limitations but quietly going about ones business is simply not enough at this level. We need game-changers. See his incredible 1v1 miss at juve last season. Gagliardini is simply not that (except against teams from Genoa). Our first choice backup needs to be someone who is either on par with our starting midfield trio, or at least, offers a strong alternative skillset - not someone who is a colossal drop of quality.
I think it was vagisilios or n4l who said about Dalbert/Joao Mario that "these are the kinds of trash that teams like Fiorentina buy for €12m, not €25m"
Personally I find that statement incredibly accurate. Pulgar moved to Fiorentina for €10m, whereas we bought Gagliardini for €28m, 3 years ago, off 15 good games..
If you asked whether I'd take a swap right now between Pulgar and Gagliardini, I'd snap your hand off then give myself a disgusting handjob with it.
Gagliardini's market value is at most, €15m or so. It certainly hasn't increased or maintained during his time at this club.