I missed out on watching the match, but can someone give me an honest, unbiased wrap of the game, was it a deserved loss or an undeserved loss ?
Well, maybe we didn't deserve to lose... But we didn't deserve to win either.
We were too shaky in defense. We mustn't allow to play that bad. All talk about how shit Silvestre was (in all honesty, he was our worst player on the pitch), but so were other players. Zanetti was strangely weak in both attack and defense. IMO our second worse player after Silvestre.
We started out well, attacked them. They hit us on counter, poor marking by Silvestre, but also easy cross allowed from the right, and they scored. Handa could do nothing about the goal.
Later, we had the possession, but they hit us on counter hard, Denis missed great chance to score. Palacio had two great chances that CF good with his head must've converted, unfortunately Palacio isn't that good with his head. It was great save by Consigli as well (he had few other great saves later on). First half ended 1-0.
In the second, we started attacking. Cassano had one shot from free kick, and the second try, Guaro scored that screamer from the same position. We were great that period, had great counter just few minutes later, but Palacio slipper while crossing. And in the next attack, they scored. I don't think it was Silvestres fault, the cross came from the left, between Nagas legs, and it was Juans player, and god knows where he was.
Than the penalty came. Unexciting tho. Even if silvestre did make the tackle penalty worthy, the guy that was fouled was in offside, so... It was still stupid tackle, he was dribbled too easily before he made it, like he was an amateur... After the third Strama went all in attack, introduced Livaja, Ricky and Pereira, instead of Cambi, Zanetti and Cassano. Smart moves, but we still didn't manage to win, but only to reduce on 3-2 by Palacios great finish.
All in all, very, very weak defense, no communication between them whatsoever. Silvestre was the worst, after that Zanetti. Naga and Juan were decent, but still had their players lost in marking for few times.
Milito was also nonexistent. Cassano was below average too. Palacio was great, he ran, he fought, he scored. Guarin was BOSS, our best performer by far. Gargano made lot's of mistakes, but he assisted well on Guarins goal and was running a lot, as always. Cambi was average, imo he was played too up on the pitch, often Palacio and Cassano were behind. Pereira did well since coming in, few great tackles. Ricky was shit, lost 3-4 balls for no reason and didn't do anything productive, but i didnt expect him to do, after playing once in 3 games for 30 minutes, and when losing 3-1, away. Livaja, same as Ricky.
That's pretty much it, my view how it went. I think 2-2 or 3-3 would have been fair and square, but..