Ratings

[Gismo]

This is the place where everyone is welcome to post their very own ratings of the starting eleven Inter players in the aftermath of every official Inter match. Then I will calculate the average of each player and the team's overall average. This will give a valid and hopefully more accurate alternative to all the newspapers' ratings.

For the Roma match you can still give your vote. Then when a new match begins we will focus on that. We use the simple 1-10 scale.

Have fun!

 

[Jimmy]

This won´t work, unless you find a way to get some realistic grading. Go with the Gazzetta or Inter.it rating first of all? I meam, people give 9.5 on some performances that on a Gazzetta level would be MAYBE 8.

Personally, I prefer the Gazzetta ratings. Where it is mostly between 4-8 and if you have done a really extraordinary match, you have the chance to go above it.

 

[Handoyo]

Especially by the most optimistic Interista AKA Alexander AKA Gismo AKA you yourself.


Handyo

 

[CafeCordoba]

Jimmy said it, this won't work, if you don't give clear instructions how to "use" the ratings. You give the 1-10 scale, yeah, but that means an average game from a player should be 5. And we all know that no one will give '5' for average game (I think Gazzetta would give something like 5.5-6. But do they have a scale something like 3-10 ).

 

[Gismo]

I can set a standard or we could agree on another one.

 

[Frisko]

That's exactly what I did in the Gazzetta ratings, and I also explained their parametres for voting (4/8).

So just keep posting your ratings there, Gismo stop stealing my ideas! :fero:

 

[Gismo]

I can go by that scale. No problem.

 

[Frisko]

I can go by that scale. No problem.

So why not start from Gazzetta's ratings?

 

[Gismo]

We could include their ratings too.

 

[Frisko]

We could include their ratings too.

Yeah sure, you can always copy and paste from the original ratings thread :fero:

 

[Gismo]

Inter - Roma

Toldo 7,6

J. Zanetti 6,8
Cordoba 8,1
Mihajlovic 8,2
Favalli 7

Veron 5,4
C. Zanetti 7,4
Cambiasso 7,4
Kily 6,4

Adriano 6
Martins 5,8

Team average 6,918181818

 

[Gismo]

My ratings:

Toldo 6,5

J. Zanetti 6,5
Cordoba 6,5
Mihajlovic 6,5
Favalli 6,5

Stankovic 6
Veron 6,5
Cambiasso 6
Kily 5

Adriano 5
Vieri 5

 

[Granit]

My ratings:

Toldo 6

J. Zanetti 6
Cordoba 6
Mihajlovic 6
Favalli 6

Stankovic 6
Veron 7
Cambiasso 6,5
Kily 5

Adriano 5
Vieri 5

 

[Gismo]

Udinese - Inter

Toldo 6,25

J. Zanetti 6,375
Cordoba 6,5
Mihajlovic 6,25
Favalli 6

Stankovic 6
Veron 7,25
Cambiasso 6,75
Kily 5,25

Vieri 5,375
Adriano 5,25

Team average 6,113636364

 

[snake]

Porto - Inter

Toldo - 4
JZ - 6.5
Cordoba - 8
Matrix - 6
Favalli - 6
C.Zanetti - 6
Cambiasso - 6.5
Veron - 6.5
Stankovic - 5
Adriano - 5.5
Martins - 6.5

 

[Serb]

Porto - Inter

Toldo - 4
JZ - 6.5
Cordoba - 8
Matrix - 5.5
Favalli - 6
C.Zanetti - 6
Cambiasso - 6.5
Veron - 6.5
Stankovic - 5
Adriano - 5.5
Martins - 6.5

Your ratings of Materazzi and Stankovic are too low, IMHO.

 

[snake]

I know you like Stankovic. But please, dont use tunnel vision. Its very obvious that for a while now Stankovic has been a shadow of himself.

Every1 can see this and the media even asks mancini why he still plays him, so its no secret Stankovic isnt doing anything.

2nd, other then the assist. he did nothing all game. simple as that.

And matrix...ok i agree he deserves 6. i just rememberd

but, whats with him and giving away free kicks in dangerous positions for no reasons? most of the times he does it is when the player isnt going nowhere so why make it easy and give them afree kick.

 

[Serb]

I know you like Stankovic. But please, dont use tunnel vision. Its very obvious that for a while now Stankovic has been a shadow of himself.

Every1 can see this and the media even asks mancini why he still plays him, so its no secret Stankovic isnt doing anything.

2nd, other then the assist. he did nothing all game. simple as that.

And matrix...ok i agree he deserves 6. i just rememberd

but, whats with him and giving away free kicks in dangerous positions for no reasons? most of the times he does it is when the player isnt going nowhere so why make it easy and give them afree kick.

I myself said he has been struggling the past 2-3 months, remember.

It has nothing to do with me liking him, or him being Serbian or whatever.

Without him, Inter not only not score an away goal, they also lose the game.

If that was Adriano, you think he would have passed to Martins or would he have gone staright for goal? Yeah.

 

[Gismo]

Porto - Inter

Toldo 4
J. Zanetti 6,75
Cordoba 7,5
Materazzi 6
Favalli 6
Stankovic 5,75
Veron 6,5
Cambiasso 6,75
C. Zanetti 6
Martins 6,75
Adriano 6

Team average 6,181818182

 

[Gismo]

Suddenly one gets an idea out of nowhere! Because of the massive lack of interest in it I have decided to quit doing it! So I urge the administrators to delete the topic!

Clearly a lot of people enjoyed the fun while it lasted!! To all of you I would like to thank you for your interest and tell you in person how much I enjoyed playing it with you guys!!

Ciao,
Alex