Funny thing is the first few months of last season there were matches where Ibra didn't complain at all or very little, probably because Mourinho told him to, and basicly the whole forum was complaining that the team put in "effortless" and "lethargic" displays. I remember it clearly, because I thought there was a connection, and still do. Regardless of what we think of his complaining, he had huge respect amongst the team, and therefore if he's shouting at them it keeps them on their toes. I do agree that he went overboard with it last season though.
Well to be honest I don't remember that. I remember him appologising sometimes, but unfortunetly I remember a lot more when he complained.
I'm ok, when a player who is obviously better tells partner to do it this way, or this way another time, but when he screems at a partner that is a big turno off for me. Even Barcelona has players who are great technicaly and not so great. I never seen for example, that Messi or Iniesta shouted at a teammate for wrong pass etc.
Truth to be told, Jordan was very competetive and screamed a lot at his teammates, mostly on the trainings, and I ver often compared both personalities. But, that doesn't mean I like it.
Regarding Ibra not being critical of himself. How many times have you seen him punch his hands together, scream into the clouds, or kick something when he does a mistake? How many times have you seen him put his hand up and apologize when he's given a bad pass, or not passed fast enough? I've seen this all the time, so I can't agree with you there.
To be honest, I remember more occasions when he did something wrong, lost a ball, passed bad and didn't do anything, but maybe it's just me.
Besides, with some of the matches we've had he's had good reason to complain. You want to see a moaner that has nothing to complain about? Watch some of C.Ronaldo's matches of 07/08 and 08/09.
XL, I would be ok with it, if it happened in all the teams. I mean there are many teams, that have a star who should play there, but is playing there, and they are not complaining etc.
I'm sure that it changed a lot last year, because I didn't noticed it before, meaning either he didn't do it as much, or he didn't do it at all.
You could see it in different ways. Either he wanted partners to play better, or he thought he is to good... I'm not accusing him of that, but for me, when I saw a lot more of him complaining, than acknoleding his own mistakes, I tend to wonder... and you know with Ibra personality, he isn't a humble guy, we all know about his ego. I don't know anybdoy who is very critical of himself, and is called a big ego. The figures just doesn't add up :>