- Joined
- Jan 17, 2005
- Messages
- 34,676
- Likes
- 17,471
10 years of FIF
Nostradamus
Most Passionate Member
Icardi is not an elite level striker. Elite level would have been someone like Eto'o. You're telling me Icardi is at that level?
Icardi is an elite level striker when he is compared to his generation and the currently active players.
The kid Haaland is also reaching elite levels, that doesn't make him an all time great.
If I compare him with Pele, Adriano, Ronaldo, Eto'o, Shevchenko, Romario, Batistuta, Ibrahimovic, Gerd Muller, Fuskas and Eusebio then he's nowhere near that level. Does it really matter? There's virtually no striker on that kind of level these days and Icardi is part of the ceiling which includes Lewandowski and Luis Suarez.
And Eto'o would sometimes be benched if he was playing with Messi, Zlatan/Villa and Henry. That wouldn't make him a lesser player. He was never in such a situation.
Ronaldo and Vieri were benched by Ventola, Zamorano and a declining Roberto Baggio. Were they scrubs?
Zanetti himself was usually benched for many years and was not a guaranteed starter. Was he also a scrub?