Well, having the Inter captaincy doesn't save anyone from being picked on or hated on. Not only Icardi and Ranocchia before Handanovic, but even Javier freaking Zanetti was called out a lot here for random (non)reasons.
Why should the captaincy exonerate anyone from criticism? The criticism needs to be looked at in a case-by-case basis too.
At the end of the day, there's only so much you can change a player. I remember people criticising Zanetti for not "doing enough" (and Cambiasso for being a "traffic cop" and only pointing). But those particular criticisms were misplaced. Zanetti was never some Modric-like midfielder, he wasn't even a fucking midfielder by trade. People expecting him, or Cambiasso, to start pinging the ball around and make plays were obviously misplacing their frustration in our stagnant Stramaccioni football.
Likewise the criticism of Icardi of being too static is one thing - because he is what he is. But I think it's more than fair to question whether we were better off replacing him with a more involved and functional forward, and fair to criticise his captaincy - and his classless whore of a wife.
This thread has turned into one of the FIF lows.
It's as if whenever people comment here they forget that they're not playing on their video games.
You'll go to extraordinary lengths to blame, no, even worse actually, take credit away, from the likes of Marotta, Conte and Lukaku, all of whom I've also heavily criticised too. But you'll go to equally extraordinary lengths to exonerate Handanovic for every thing he does. It's incredible.
Even if you take the "questionable" or "debatable" errors out of the equation, you're left with the undeniable fact that his inexplicable, unforced errors (where there is no possible culprit other than Handanovic) have increased significantly.
I suppose Handanovic passing it straight to a Verona player was Brozovic's fault. Or last season at the same ground when he dropped the ball at Skriniar's feet from a completely innocuous cross, that was Skriniar's fault too.
Handanovic is donezo like funzo. Half the time these days dude won't even stick out a hand by 20cm to save a perfectly saveable shot. His instincts seem to be fried. Or perhaps his body can no longer follow or obey that instinct.