My point was if he was just under meazza or maybe even our all time top scorer would we not rate him higher than milito? Or does it depend on the trophies?
Just a random thought if icardi goes on to be a top 2 or 3 fw in our history yet we don't win anything does it make him less of a legend than milito?
The thing with Milito is, his first season with us was absolutely incomparable. He was a fucking beast and total boss that season. That was Milito at his best. Not sure if Icardi can ever reach that level, he has the potential of course.
But Icardi without a doubt is a more ruthless finisher.