Gianluca Scamacca

Status
Not open for further replies.

Jane The Virgin

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Aug 30, 2010
Messages
4,184
Likes
850
Favorite Player
Barella
Old username
the dude
10 years of FIF
If you don’t gamble you never win.

if you only go by the safe choice then with Inter budget you will be stuck in mediocrity forever, we already tried that approach that didn’t really turn out that well the last time around. You can not sail safe through this, because the sealing of the safe bet isn’t always that high. We also took the safe bet on Correa, see how that turned out or rather what Inter thought was safe, as it massively backfired.

We also gamble with Frattesi and Samardzic, we could have chosen more safe bet more experienced but we chose players with a potential higher sealing. That is what will move the club up, it might not be successful every single time but when it dos it pays off.

Let’s not forget the Gamble Inter took with Martinez and Bastoni, we could not for certain know these guys would end where they did, what we would have missed out on if we didn’t take that gamble and Inter payed over 30m for a complete unproven defender.

Also Balagun had a much much better Season scoring more then 20 goals…
You're giving me a tedtalk about carpe diem, I'm trying to have a real Convo about the reality of Inter.

Since you mentioned gambling, even a greater gamble is a random 17 year old Brazilian kid from Rio. We can do this all day...

Going back to the tedtalk, everything is a gamble in life. A safe choice would've been keeping Dzeko for another year.

Scamacca at the moment is a better player than Balogun.

I said that whatever "measuring system"/scale you use for Balogun, with the same standard Scamacca is a better player using the same "scale".

What is available to me and you at the moment are just videos online from them. If we take their best seasons and compare them, clearly Scamacca is much dangerous in front of the goal, is bigger/taller, stronger, has scored in the league Inter plays, many many many times.

But you aren't choosing their best seasons. You choose Scamaccas worst season vs. Baloguns best.

Look at the wiki stats from his season in Middlesbrough, 20 appearances and 3 goals. Where was this wiz kid you all talk about then? Oh was he too young? In a very physical league, the coach didn't understand him, he wasn't treated fair? Was he hurt? What was keeping him from "carrying the team on his shoulders"?


Again, I'm talking about a better player at the moment, and a better deal for Inter. Scamacca is a more finished product. There isn't as much room for guessing with him, give or take you know what you're buying.

I feel balogun is a scam. I don't see him being good in Italy or in a seriös league.
 

Jane The Virgin

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Aug 30, 2010
Messages
4,184
Likes
850
Favorite Player
Barella
Old username
the dude
10 years of FIF
How is Scammaca better than Balogun right now? One is coming off a season scoring 1 league goal vs another who scored like 20????
I guess I'm just racist, right? Lol
 

brehme1989

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Jan 17, 2005
Messages
34,591
Likes
17,352
10 years of FIF
Nostradamus
Most Passionate Member
People are just making stuff up now. The same way I had to read people compare him to Pinamonti last summer.
And probably the same people wanted Pinamonti to start over Lautaro
 

Hikonyán

Primavera
Primavera
Joined
Apr 28, 2021
Messages
341
Likes
475
Scamacca a more finished product? :LOL:

He has had one semi-good season in his entire career, despite being 24 already. Balogun a one season wonder? What is scamacca then? One good season then becoming a total flop in the EPL?

Scamacca obviously isnt better than Balogun currently. Ludicrous to say otherwise.

You are only as good as your current season and Scamacca has been a flop + serious injury for the past year, while Balogun had his big breakthrough.

Balogun is younger, better currently, has alot more potential and far more aspects to his game than the totempole that is scamacca who can little else than shooting. We need players that take part in buildup plays, not totempoles.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gal

brightbackground

Prima Squadra
Prima Squadra
Joined
Aug 29, 2020
Messages
810
Likes
1,574
Scamacca has 'fringe low impact player on a high salary that cant be gotten rid of before his contract expires' - written all over him.

The Gagliardini of forwards, extremely limited.

The sad thing is, he already is that for West Ham. He's their Correa, and just like no sane club is going for Correa none should for Scamacca. But I guess we are Pazza Inter after all.
 

dynasty27

Problema muscolare
La Grande Inter
Joined
Jan 28, 2010
Messages
12,613
Likes
826
10 years of FIF
Any good recent examples of young strikers suffering from injuries and still able to revive their career?
 

IM21

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Jan 9, 2015
Messages
13,036
Likes
26,257
Aren't they effectively the same source? I thought Romano worked for Di Marzio and just translated his stuff for English-language engagement.
i've noticed Romano is just stealing from Di marzio and makes his tweets fancy with the picture.
 

Gal

Capitano
Capitano
Joined
Jul 18, 2022
Messages
1,470
Likes
1,122
You're giving me a tedtalk about carpe diem, I'm trying to have a real Convo about the reality of Inter.

Since you mentioned gambling, even a greater gamble is a random 17 year old Brazilian kid from Rio. We can do this all day...

As I wrote sometime you win sometimes you loose. I grant you some of those in the past where pure stupidity, but then you know Branca.

I also didn’t say one should take unreasonable gambles, but it is necessary with some gamble.
Going back to the tedtalk, everything is a gamble in life. A safe choice would've been keeping Dzeko for another year.

Scamacca at the moment is a better player than Balogun.
No he ain’t, last year Balagun scored more then 20 goals, what did Scamacca do besides being injured?

I said that whatever "measuring system"/scale you use for Balogun, with the same standard Scamacca is a better player using the same "scale".

I’m using the one where one actually played and performed the other was hardly even playing. Like what was it 16 games Scamacca got!
What is available to me and you at the moment are just videos online from them. If we take their best seasons and compare them, clearly Scamacca is much dangerous in front of the goal, is bigger/taller, stronger, has scored in the league Inter plays, many many many times.
Yes and Correa also had Serie A experience, how was that turning out. The serie A experience isn’t always the sort of guarantee for success as people make it out to be and it ain’t really the first time.

if you watched Scamacca you know he ain’t really that great, he had one good season that’s it. I never seen anything in that lad, some people rating of him is mind buggering.

But you aren't choosing their best seasons. You choose Scamaccas worst season vs. Baloguns best.

That just happened to be the last, it’s not like majority of Scamacca season where all that spectacular, as I wrote he had one good the rest was not really worth of note.
Look at the wiki stats from his season in Middlesbrough, 20 appearances and 3 goals. Where was this wiz kid you all talk about then? Oh was he too young? In a very physical league, the coach didn't understand him, he wasn't treated fair? Was he hurt? What was keeping him from "carrying the team on his shoulders"?
He was like 20 years old seriously what was Scamacca doing at that age exactly.

Scamacca was hardly even scoring goals at that age. At Balagun age he was scoring like 8 goals tops.
Again, I'm talking about a better player at the moment, and a better deal for Inter. Scamacca is a more finished product. There isn't as much room for guessing with him, give or take you know what you're buying.

I feel balogun is a scam. I don't see him being good in Italy or in a seriös league.
He ain’t any better, he is not even a very good player. He had one fine season that’s it all the remaining seasons was largely forgettable.

This kid has already scores plus 20 goals, sure in france but in a defensive league for not the greatest of teams, I doubt we ever see Scamacca score even half of that.

Is he a new super star prospect probably not, but he for sure is more interesting then the mediocre Scamacca who is never going to be remotely better then 4th choice material.

€30m is currently the price for injury plagued mediocre scamacca, you think that is money well spend?

Yes if Balagun is €50-60m then its obviously a no go, the gamble becomes to high and potential profit too low… But if we talk €35-40m I do think It will be worth the shot.
 
Last edited:

Il Drago

Moderator
Moderator
Joined
Dec 21, 2015
Messages
20,824
Likes
32,745
Favorite Player
Wesley Sneijder
Best Football Poster
Best Overall Poster
And probably the same people wanted Pinamonti to start over Lautaro

When was that exactly? When Lautaro joined Inter Pinamonti was at Frosinone. Then the following season he was at Genoa. The only time they coexisted was in Scudetto season when Lautaro was a definite starter and no one was asking for Pinamonti to start.

Instead i remember the entire forum bashing Spalletti in 2018/19 for not starting Lautaro-Icardi attacking duo.
 

M.Adnan

La Grande Inter
La Grande Inter
Joined
Feb 7, 2005
Messages
10,360
Likes
1,268
Favorite Player
Tomas Locatelli
10 years of FIF
Forum Supporter
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top